It is not only for what we do that we are held responsible,
but also for what we do not do...
Date : Friday, July 30, 2010
Time : 11:28 AM
Title : Airline sued for $7 million over lost bag

This is the first legal action of its kind since American Airlines started charging a fee for handling and transporting check-in luggage.

A WOMAN who was upset when American Airlines lost her luggage became more upset when they refused to refund her a US$25 (S$34) luggage handling fee.

She's now filed a US$5 million (S$7m) class action lawsuit against the airline. This is the first legal action of its kind since American Airlines started charging a fee for handling and transporting check-in luggage since June 2008.

Ms Danielle Covarrubias, 35, took a flight from Seattle, Washington to Grand Rapids, Michigan, last Mayand paid a US$25 luggage handling fee for one piece of check-in luggage. It did not arrive at the destination.

Ms Covarrubias waited for the next flight, but her bag containing US$800 worth of items was not on the flight.

Nothing done

She spent US$300 on newclothing and toiletries and waited a day for an update from the airline.

"In her last conversation with American Airlines, she was told nothing could be done," the lawsuit said. The airline also refused herdemandfor a refund of the baggage fee.

"This case is about an entire industry that has lost touch with its customers," said Ms Covarrubias' lawyer Casey Ingels in a statement.

Speaking through her lawyers, Ms Covarrubias said: "American Airlines is just another example of how companies have forgotten about customer service.

"When American charges a fee for a baggage service, it should deliver your bag, unharmed, or give you a refund."
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Daren:
..When most of us lose our luggage, we get mad, or maybe throw a tantrum and will request the airline in question for help. However, this is not the case for Danielle Covarrubias of Tacoma. Instead of requesting help, she filed a $5 million class-action lawsuit against American Airlines for not only losing her luggage; but refusing to pay her back for the baggage fee.
..In my perspective, I personally felt that the $5 million class-action lawsuit is a little bit too much. Yes, it is true that she should be compensated for the lost of her luggage. However, that’s a bit excessive that she should be compensated for the amount of $5 million. I think that people should place expensive belongings in their own bags rather than inside the luggage. Thus, when the luggage is lost, the expensive belongings will remain intact. It could be Danielle Covarrubias negligence and should not entirely blame it on the airline.
..I know exactly how this victim feels because I have experienced the same thing as her when my luggage was lost when travelling to Malaysia. Luckily, I do not have much expensive stuffs in my luggage. But most of the items were things that no amount will be able to replace; my old family photos and keychain from my father. Even if I were to sue for millions, I will never be able to get those priceless treasures back.

Allyson:
..After reading this article, I feel that American Airlines is being very inconsiderate and unreasonable. Since American Airlines charges customers baggage fees, they should take full responsibility of taking care of the customer’s luggage and make sure they get their belongings back. Even if American Airlines really did accidentally lose the luggages of customers, the least they can do is to refund those customers their baggage fee.
..According to court documents filed in her lawsuit, American Airlines damages, loses or delays more than 2,400 pieces of luggage a day. If this is indeed true, something should be quickly done to solve this horrible problem that should not be happening at all. This shows that the service in American Airlines is not good. Therefore, after people read this article, they would most likely not want to travel with American Airlines in case the same situation happens to them. If this carries on, American Airlines should not operate at all since it is giving so much trouble to customers.
..Danielle Covarrubias has filed a $5 million class-action lawsuit against American Airlines for not only losing her luggage but also refusing to reimburse her for the baggage fee. However, her luggage only consists of more than $800 worth of clothing and personal items. I feel that filing a $5 million class-action lawsuit against American Airlines is slightly overboard and she is over-reacting. There is no need to file $5 million when the amount she lost is much lesser. Therefore, both sides have their rights and wrongs.

Suganthi:
..American Airlines, Inc. (AA) is a major airline of the United States and is the world's second largest airline (behind Delta Air Lines) in passenger miles transported, passenger fleet size, and operating revenues. The American Airlines also started charging a fee for handling and transporting check-in luggage since June 2008. Considering the good reputation of the airlines the accusation against it really gives us a shock.
..From the view of the 35 year old Ms Danielle Covarrubias it is right for her to be angry when she paid US$25 fee charge for the check- in baggage waiting to receive her baggage in her destination instead the baggage did not appear even after many hours. Added to this situation, the airlines provided her with poor customer service by making her wait for very long and gave a reply that there were no updates about airlines.
..Customer service is very important in the airlines department; customers have to be always given importance and also for their belongings, as it will reflect on the reputation and image of the airport. By the above act of the airport, and if Ms Covarrubias insists of suing the airlines it will then tarnish their reputation.
..Therefore i would really feel that the airport department should get down to action to retrieve her baggage and apologise to her for making her wait. Another possible thing to make her cool herself and give up on the lawsuit is to immediately arrange for her baggage and refund the baggage check in fee. The airport has to make sure this will not happen again.

Jane:
..Danielle Covarrubias flew from Seattle to Grand Rapids, MI on American Airlines and checked her bag on the flight, paying the required fee of $25 to do so. When she arrived at her destination, her bag is missing. She's suing American Airlines for $5 million after the airline refused to refund the $25 checked bag fee.
..Ben Baldanza the CEO of America Airline says that, carrying more than one bag is not necessary for all travellers and he believe it is unfair to charge those customers for extra services they do not use. But in my opinion, I felt that it is necessary to take more than one bag because if the people is travel to a far country and need to bring their thing that they sure need more than one bags.
..Besides, I am glad that the women is suing the airlines because nowadays the service provide by the airlines is poor. One example is, although the airline is a lower prices airline they still have to provide their service properly and nice to their customers. If don’t have these group of customers their company will not exceed and they will never get profit in this industry.
..At last, I hope that the airline company can re-train their staff and make the increase the awareness in the airport. And I also feel sympathize to the women that lose her bag.

Hafizah:
..After reading this article, I have to say that it might be the airport’s fully responsibility for the passenger’s missing luggage. If I were the lady, I would definitely feel the same way as she does right now. Missing my luggage which contains a lot of my personal, important valuables would definitely turn me into a depressed person after a refreshing and wonderful trip from overseas.
..Although we were always reminded to take good care of our belongings, but at some point of time it will the airport’s responsibility to keep it safe. We as the passenger cannot be holding on to our big luggage all the way as we need to check in our luggage first before boarding the plane and from that point of time, it is the airport’s responsibility. Until we reached our destination, we expect to collect our luggage back.
..I believed this is not the first time this kind of cases happened. There is a similar one where a passenger did not get back his or her luggage as it was accidentally transferred to another plane travelling to other country. But somehow the airport attendants worked it out and get the luggage back to that person.
..In future, I hope this kind of problem would not happen again because losing someone’s personal belongings is very troublesome as we have to be responsible for those ourselves. Also, we have to bare the consequences to pay for the charges. Not only the passengers have to be responsible, everybody including the worker has to be careful too.



Profile

GROUP 2

AD

Photobucket
SUGANTHI D/O A. TAIYALAN
106551W
04 August 1988
Photobucket
CHEONG CHIOK CHING
104691K
12 February 1991
Photobucket
NUR HAFIZAH BINTE MD YUSOOF
106393K
26 April 1991
Photobucket
DAREN LOW ZHENGHAN
101592R
27 September 1992
Photobucket
ALLYSON LIM XIN HUI
102732F
12 May 1993


Links

GROUP 1
GROUP 3
GROUP 4
GROUP 5
GROUP 6


...






Archives

May 2010
June 2010
July 2010

Credits

Designer